Home / Line Items / Exhibit B
Exhibit B

Exhibit B: An Outpatient Surgery Bill, Annotated

Every number on a scheduled surgery bill was knowable in advance, which means every number was negotiable in advance. Here is the redline, and the building that would have changed it.

Cash Medical · Updated September 2026 · 6 min read

A scheduled outpatient surgery is the opposite of the ER bill. Every number on it was knowable in advance, which means every number on it was negotiable in advance. This representative bill shows what that looks like, and what the same procedure would have cost one building over.

Exhibit B · Outpatient surgery, hospital outpatient department, illustrative composite
Facility fee, outpatient operating room$8,600$3,440
Surgeon, professional fee$2,900$1,740
Anesthesia, 90 minutes, billed by time$1,850$925
Implant and disposable supplies$3,200$1,600
Recovery room, per hour$740$296
Pathology, outside lab$380$152
four separate businesses. four separate asks.

Illustrative composite. Left column is a typical billed charge, right column a typical self-pay outcome after discount. Not a quote.

The facility fee is the decision

Over half this bill is the room. And the room is a choice, because a freestanding ambulatory surgery center charges on average 60 to 80 percent less than a hospital outpatient department for the identical procedure, according to a CMS payment comparison.

SAME PROCEDURE, DIFFERENT BUILDING Hospital outpatient dept Ambulatory surgery center 60-80% less, per CMS payment comparison Identical procedure, identical codes. The variable that moved was the site of service, not the negotiation.
Same codes, same surgeon in many cases. The variable is the building.

Transparent-price centers make the comparison concrete. The Surgery Center of Oklahoma publishes all-inclusive prices including a total knee replacement at $17,679 and a laparoscopic gallbladder removal at $6,836, with the facility, surgeon, and anesthesia bundled into one number and no negotiation required.

Anesthesia is billed by the clock

Anesthesia is usually billed in time units rather than as a flat fee, which means a longer procedure produces a larger anesthesia bill even when nothing went wrong. Ask before the procedure whether anesthesia is flat or time-based, and who employs the anesthesiologist, because it is frequently an independent group that bills you separately.

The implant line is the widest variable

Devices, implants, and disposables are marked up at institutional discretion and swing more than any other line on a surgical bill. The question to ask in advance is whether the device is billed at cost, cost plus a percentage, or list price. It is a question most patients never ask and most billing offices can answer.

What should have happened before any of this

  1. Good Faith Estimate, in writing, covering facility, surgeon, anesthesia, implant, and pathology as separate lines. See the estimate guide.
  2. The hospital's published cash price for the specific codes, pulled from its machine-readable file.
  3. A quote from an ambulatory surgery center for the same codes.
  4. The self-pay discount policy from each of the four billing entities, in writing.
  5. An international cash price for the same procedure, all in.

Steps 1 through 4 are the American toolkit, and worked well they can cut this bill roughly in half. Step 5 is the one most people skip, and for elective procedures it is frequently the one that moves the number most.

The honest limit of the redline

Look at the right-hand column again. A perfectly executed self-pay negotiation on this bill still lands in five figures. That is not a failure of the negotiation. It is the American cash price, correctly obtained. For medically necessary care with no alternative, that is the number, and financial assistance is the next lever.

For elective and semi-elective procedures, dental, vision, fertility, cosmetic, and a good deal of orthopedics, it is the point where the comparison stops being domestic.

When the cash price still does not close the gap

The sixth line item nobody prices

Every step above moves you along the same axis, from the chargemaster to the American cash rate. That axis has an end, and for elective care the end is still expensive, because insurance was never subsidizing those procedures in the first place.

Accredited Colombian hospitals quote these procedures all-inclusive and up front, typically well below the US cash rate. Colombia's health system was ranked first in the Western Hemisphere and 22nd globally in the World Health Organization's 2000 assessment, several hospitals hold hospital-level JCI accreditation, and every licensed physician is verifiable on the government's ReTHUS registry. We live in Medellin and walk into the clinics ourselves.

Straight answers

Is this a real surgery bill?

No. It is an illustrative composite built from published charge ranges and typical self-pay outcomes, shown so the structure is legible. Every number on your own bill will differ.

Why is the facility fee larger than the surgeon's fee?

Because it covers the operating room, staff, equipment, and overhead rather than the surgeon's time. It is also the line most affected by site of service, which is why an ambulatory surgery center changes the total so dramatically.

Can I use an ambulatory surgery center for any procedure?

Not all of them. Surgery centers handle a defined set of outpatient procedures and will decline cases with higher risk profiles or significant comorbidities. Ask your surgeon whether your case is appropriate for one, and whether they have privileges there.

Should I ask about the implant price in advance?

Yes. Ask whether devices are billed at cost, cost plus a percentage, or list, and get the expected device charge included in your Good Faith Estimate. It is one of the widest-swinging lines on a surgical bill.

How many separate bills should I expect?

Commonly four: the facility, the surgeon, the anesthesia group, and pathology or an outside lab. Request an estimate from each in advance and a self-pay discount from each afterward, because they are usually separate businesses.

Is a bundled package price better than itemized?

For a cash patient, usually yes. A single all-inclusive price transfers the risk of the procedure running long onto the provider rather than onto you, which is exactly why transparent-price surgery centers and most international hospitals quote that way.

How to read the numbers on this page. Every dollar figure here is a typical 2026 range compiled from published provider pricing, transparent-price surgery centers, and government data. None of it is a quote, and none of it is a guarantee. Your bill depends on your case, your provider, and your state. Get a current itemized estimate in writing before you budget against anything you read here.

Not legal or medical advice. This is consumer education about billing rules and patient rights, written for people paying cash. It is not legal advice, and it is not a substitute for a licensed clinician. If you are considering care in Colombia, verify any physician on the Colombian government's ReTHUS registry and confirm accreditation at the hospital level before you commit to anything.

Disclosure. Cash Medical is operated by Scout Theory LLC. We may receive referral compensation from providers we connect patients with. It never changes the price you are quoted, and it never decides what we publish. Questions: andy@colombiamedical.co.